The Circus Comes to Town: Phish plays two nights in Providence

Page McConnell and Trey Anastasio from Phish perform at the Dunkin Donuts Center in Providence, RI on November 29, 2019. Photo by Doug MacGunnigle, WPRO

by Doug MacGunnigle, WPRO

The immensely popular jam-band Phish and their loyal army of fans descended on the Dunkinโ€™ Donuts Center in Providence for two nights over Thanksgiving weekend, starting their run of shows leading up to the their traditional New Years Eve residency in New York City.

Phish had played at the Dunk 6 times prior to this weekend, with the first time being in December of 1994, and the last time being in October of 2010. The band also played two strong nights as a part of the fabled 1998 โ€œIsland Tour,โ€ so named because that mini-tour only played 4 shows โ€“ two in Rhode Island and two on Long Island at the Nassau Coliseum.

Trey Anastasio and Mike Gordon from Phish perform at the Dunkin Donuts Center in Providence, RI on November 29, 2019. Photo by Doug MacGunnigle, WPRO

The long sold out concerts were a tough ticket to obtain- many were left outside the venue, either unable or unwilling to cough up the inflated ticket prices that were being offered outside the venue.

Outside the Dunk, the streets were filled with revelers, both local and from out of town. Local bars and restaurants no doubt did big business downtown this weekend โ€“ the scene outside of Trinity Brewhouse was a chaotic street party and like a homecoming weekend or reunion to many of the fans who travel across the county to catch the band perform and meet up with long lost friends.

Trey Anastasio and Jon Fishman from Phish perform at the Dunkin Donuts Center in Providence, RI on November 29, 2019. Photo by Doug MacGunnigle, WPRO

Those who made it in were treated to two solid nights of music โ€“ with the edge going to Saturday nightโ€™s show, which was more playful and centered on many of Phishโ€™s most beloved jam songs, including โ€œBathtub Ginโ€ and an incendiary take on โ€œHarry Hood.โ€

There were highlights on Friday night as well โ€“ instrumental show opener โ€œFirst Tubeโ€ displayed the technical prowess of the band, while the takes on Jimi Hendrixโ€™s โ€œFireโ€ and The James Gangโ€™s โ€œWalk Awayโ€ were crowd pleasing set-enders that were lots of fun.

Mike Gordon from Phish performs at the Dunkin Donuts Center in Providence, RI on November 29, 2019. Photo by Doug MacGunnigle, WPRO

โ€œBye Bye Foot,โ€ sung by drummer Jonathan Fishman, made itโ€™s first appearance in over 20 years on Friday, and โ€œPlasma,โ€ a tune from guitarist Trey Anastasioโ€™s solo catalog, weaved its way through Fridayโ€™s second set and Saturdayโ€™s show as well.

Bassist Mike Gordon took a couple of well received solos on Saturday night, notably during keyboardist Page McConnellโ€™s crooner โ€œLawn Boy,โ€ as well as during a slowed down take on โ€œLlama.โ€

Page McConnell from Phish performs at the Dunkin Donuts Center in Providence, RI on November 29, 2019. Photo by Doug MacGunnigle, WPRO

Drummer Jon Fishman took a trademark vacuum cleaner solo as well Saturday โ€“ yes, he makes sounds with a vacuum hose held up to his mouth, much like Peter Framptonโ€™s classic โ€˜talking guitarโ€™ effect.

The highlight of the weekend was Saturdayโ€™s second set โ€“ while the first set was fun and goofy with Anastasioโ€™s song introductions (something the band rarely does) and keyboarist McConnellโ€™s โ€œTHXโ€ sound effect beginning each song (a gag that continued through the second set) โ€“ the band really opened up in set two โ€“ the aforementioned โ€œBathtub Ginโ€ and โ€œHarry Hoodโ€ anchored the set, with โ€œHoodโ€ especially providing some transcendent moments. Also of note was a strong take on โ€œAlaska,โ€ and the reappearance several times in the show of the main theme from Fridayโ€™s โ€œPlasma.โ€

Page McConnell and Trey Anastasio from Phish perform at the Dunkin Donuts Center in Providence, RI on November 29, 2019. Photo by Doug MacGunnigle, WPRO

Phish closed out the weekend of shows with an encore consisting of a ferocious โ€œBig Black Furry Creatures from Mars,โ€ โ€œKung,โ€ โ€œWombat,โ€ and finally โ€œPossum,โ€ capped off with, of course, the main riff of โ€œPlasma.โ€

Mike Gordon from Phish performs at the Dunkin Donuts Center in Providence, RI on November 29, 2019. Photo by Doug MacGunnigle, WPRO

If you are one who follows the band to every show, youโ€™d likely have a take that differed from a first-timer โ€“ there was lots of talk outside the venue Saturday before the show that Friday was not one of the bandโ€™s strongest efforts โ€“ but one would have to think that even the most die-hard fans would find something to love in the Providence run of shows.

The front row takes in the Phish show at the Dunkin Donuts Center in Providence, RI on November 29, 2019. Photo by Doug MacGunnigle, WPRO

Phish is an acquired taste, both the music and the scene, but there were many thousands of happy revelers in Providence this weekend, and the local authorities seemed to find the right mix of enforcement โ€“ unless someone was acting like a real jerk people werenโ€™t getting cited for open containers or marijuana consumption.

Trey Anastasio from Phish performs at the Dunkin Donuts Center in Providence, RI on November 29, 2019. Photo by Doug MacGunnigle, WPRO

Police did crack down on the sale of nitrous balloons by Saturday, although they were prevalent around downtown on Friday. It was also entertaining to see the folks in town for other reasons to interact with the Phish community. While people were generally respectful, there was no doubt that when the band comes to town, they take it over. Thereโ€™s also no doubt that the spike to local businesses downtown made this a welcome event for the city of Providence.

More from 630WPRO.COM